Butter130 S. Green St.
312-666-9813
ok, so the name is kinda stupid. i thought the whole snappy one word title thing was done a long time ago, but it keeps coming back. flare. chip. eat. fleur. crap. whatever. ok, but seriously - i found this in the new openings section of metromix and it's new american, which is one of my favorite foods, so that was promising - and then the clincher is one of the dudes worked at
french laundry, which is this fancy pants place in napa valley that my brother creams his pants whenever he talks about it - so it's got some foodie cred. one christmas i got him a
cookbook from there and all the stuff has these cutesy names like "peanut butter and jellys" - which i made the jelly squares, and the peanut butter was like this fancy peanut butter dipped in this stupidly good chocolate... so the gist of the aesthetic is basically - fancy pants food, but kinda funned up, or dumbed down or whatever to these classic food pairings. rather than call someing, oh i dunno... "roasted quail in red-wine and mushroom reduction sauce with seared baby carrots and parsnip and potato puree" they'd just call it QUAIL or something. essentially trying to "de-pretentious-ize" (i made that word up) food - which i'm totally about. good food rules. pretentious food is lame. although, even when it's pretentious, it's still pretty awesome... i just like the less prentenious stuff.
so, i pick out the place. we drive up and it's got a really stupid sign. and i hate the exterior color. when we walk in, the little opening hallway is nice, i really like the dark stained wood and some of the modern brushed aluminum accents. (i'm not gay, fuck off). but i don't like how big the place is. it seems a little, impresonal i guess. whatever. i like small restaurants. our hostess is nice - maybe a little overcompensating in the nice department for my tastes - clearly they're instructed to be super nice. she's ok with me though. i got no beef with her. we sit down, she hands us the menus and they're in these wierd plastic coated cover things, and they have subsections called out in these "whimsical" fonts which annoy me. i'm still getting over how i don't like how big it is (keep in mind this is relative, i'm probably making this sound like a gym or something, it's just larger than i generally like). our server comes over and introduces herself and she's real nice, i like her. she's professional enough and knows her shit, but she's also pretty down to earth. i could imagine having a beer with her bitching about shitty clients or something. a few seconds later a team swoops in with what i assume to be the
amuse - it looks like potato chips, pop corn and oyster crackers. they explain: home made potato chips with sea salt cooked in fancy oil. pop corn in an herb truffle oil i think. and oyster crackers with some other fancyness. skeptical i am, then my mind flashes to french laundry. ahhh, this is exactly the same aesthetic. i take a bite, holy shit. this is good. pop corn is amazing. i keep laughing that im eating such "crappy" food at such a "nice" place, and how amazing the "crappy" food tastes compared to the normal "crappy" food.
wine
we decide on our meal and pick a bottle of wine. i have a taste for the sancerre since that's one of my favorites and goes well with our respective main courses (halibut & salmon), but it's also kinda pricey. i go for the cheapest bottle of sauvignon blanc they have, since this dinner is totally blowing the fancy dinner budget for the next month or two.
wine sidebar: so, sauvignon blanc is just the type of grape. and american wines describe them by the type of grape. french wines go by the region they're in. so a sancerre is a white wine made of sauvignon blanc grapes from the sancerre region of france. easy enough right? i know i like sancerre. so i just get a cheaper american version of the same thing and boom we're off. there's also the added generalization of white for fish/chicken, red for meat. pork's kind of a fence sitter, and depends on the accompanying sauce - if of course it's prepared in a "red wine reduction" - dumbass, get a red wine with it. whatever, those are my rules anyway.
the first 10 minutes in the restaurant are always stressful for me because i'm trying really hard to come up with what i'm going to eat, and how the appetiser is going to mesh with the main course, and then how what i'm having is going to coincide with what my hot date is having, and what wine is gonna bring all those together, so i'm usually silent for the first 10 mins or so until i have this all mapped out. if people haven't eaten with me before it throws them off at first, but i really hate people asking me things before i have my plan of attack mapped out.
amuse
so the waitress comes back and we order, thank god - i can relax and enjoy myself. 30 seconds later a new amuse comes in, and i realise this is the real amuse, and the first bit was an amuse, amuse. well done butter, you had me duped. this one looked like the real deal. a cold pear and parsnip soup with an infused oil. it came in what looked like a shot glass. my hot date was confused because it was a soup and we had no spoons. i said, look, you slam it like it's a shot. she didn't believe me and waited for me to go first. it was awesome. i pretended not to hear that there was pear in it, because really, i don't like pears. but this gave you much more of parsnip-y, root vegetable flavor with a floral, kinda herb like finish. it was also lightly foamed at the top (just enough to be interesting, but not annoying - i'm not big into the foam fad.) so, all in all it was a big shot, like a shot and a half at a bar. and it totally started turning me into a believer. i started sipping on the wine and looked up and discovered an awesome view of some skyscrapers.
bread
very important to me, and usually says a lot about the resaurant. what exactly it says, i dunno. whether or not i like it i guess. and the butter they serve with it (or olive oil depending) is super important. bread here was good. grainy in a good way. i'm prejudiced to white french loaf, but i hear grains are better for you, so this was quite good. butter served in a real nice flattened off dish that looks like a candleholder for a tea light. real nice.
app
i ordered the risotto because it had the same herb truffle oil that the popcorn was in and the waitress recommended it as awesome. hot date had the ceaser salad. what struck me about both was how light they were. both can be really heavy and crappy depending on where you get them. the risotto was very airy and also had wild mushrooms and asparagus in it. the flavor was really delicate and complex at the same time - it sort of lingered with you in a smooth fonzie kind of way. the ceaser came out really uniquely - it had the leaves laid out like big steaks almost, yet it was pre-tossed. croutons were of course home made and were big and sort of flaky in a good way, not crunchy and hard. even though i hate anchovies, i tried a bit at the urging of hot date. she loves the anchovies. i must admit, it added a new, pretty good dimension to the salad.
entree
i had the halibut (also recommended by the waitress, but also what i was going to order before she recommended it) and it was awesome. the outside layer was a golden brown crispy, and had some crunch just on the very top and bottom, yet the inside wasn't overcooked at all, but was light and textural. this is just awesome, and one thing i love about cooking, when you get the contrast of textures in a single item. paired was asparagus again, this time in two very manageable spears of maybe 3", wild mushrooms amd onions, all in a light sauce. this was just stupid good. i had a bite of hot date's salmon, and it was good, but it was the halibut's night. i asked for another round of bread and polished off the wine. feelin good.
around now i start to soak up the atmosphere a bit. there's a table to the right of us with 9 trixies that look like they'd be a pain in the ass to wait on, and another table to the left of older people who look a little uncomfortable in a place that's trying to be sort of young and cool yet down to earth. ubiquitous dance music is playing in the background, i can't place it - but it's that anonymous sounding music that says "we're young and cool, but still sorta have money" - it sounds like the soundtrack to
the l word (shane is such a bad-ass, fuck jenny-she sucks. i also like alice and dana). but i'm definitely feeling this place the more we're here.
desert
desert menu comes and we pick a flight of cremes. vanilla, chocolate & pistachio, and cappucino, and a pair of coffees. there's a lot of fruit on the menu (hot date speculates "that's cuz chick's like fruit") but as you know i'm not down with that. the flight of cremes is totally down my alley. it's light and cleanses the pallete. salute butter! despite all these bad first impressions, you have slayed/melted my face indeed! it leaves me with a totally different taste in the pallete and i've experienced 5 (7 counting picking off hot dates plate) significantly different, yet all very good flavors/experiences/quasi-courses.
hot date runs to the bathroom to checkitout and reports that it's awesome, and they even have free tampons and perfume and crap in there. i can't believe it and run to the guys room and it's just like a crappy(fancy) airport bathroom. they clearly spent time catering to the ladies on this one, dudes - we're left out, but our dates will love it. this makes sense in retrospect i guess. the owners wanted butter to feel like the places you'd see the girls in sex & the city hang out at, and well - i think they suceeded.
get the bill and it hits... whoooa. ok. that was super rad, but it also is gonna hafta tide my over for a while. dinner for 2: $175 inc tip & wine. (remember i got the cheap wine too). it's back to the taqueria and KOB tonight.
while we're leaving, the douchebag at the table next to us mentions to his not very attractive lady companion "when i was A&R at a major label blah blah blah". so that's the kind of company that's there if you know what i'm saying. we walked out and were greeted by a bently in valet in front. i was really looking forward to having a night with nothing to do with the music business, and there we go - just as we're walking out.
so, in summation. if you're one of my friends, and have money saved to go out, it is worth it. this is a "eat here like once a year kinda place". i like to go to fancy places like once a month or so, and this one can stay on the list for revisits, though it's a hair over what i usually like to spend on my fancy pants meals - there are a TON of great restaurants in this city. they made a big to do in thier menu about being not pretentious food and being accesible and all that, and i think they suceeded nicely. if you're a kid who hangs at the empty bottle and club foot a lot, it still very well seem pretentious, but it ain't no trotters. for your avergage trashy food eater, this place is still pretty fancy pants, make no mistake - but as far as fancy pants restaurants goes, this does real nice at merging the two. hot date picks the next destination, which will probably be one of her hole-in-the-wall neoghborhood places which are super rad too. and much cheaper! we complement each other nicely.
length of dining experience: 2 hrs
length of to write this post: 1.5 hrs
winner in fun factor: dining